AI on Chromebooks, does it help or hurt?

This is an advertisement for AI assistance on flash cards. This ad was sent to a student on February fourth. Photo credit to Walker Nunley.

This article was written by Walker Nunley

You’re teaching a class and you see a student using AI to cheat on an assignment, limiting their learning. However, the next day you see a student asking AI valuable questions, and utilizing it in a positive manner. The question of banning AI is a hot debate for staff. Not letting people use AI would not be fair to the student who has only utilized it properly, but not removing the issue of a lacking learning environment, is also a problem. 

This is a very relevant issue since AI has changed what learning looks like. Using AI to understand how to do a specific math formula shows that it can be a great tool, however somebody using the exact same AI for cheating on an assignment shows how it can impact students negatively. I think blocking AI as a whole is not necessary, but AI should have some restrictions. AI has affected students’ education in positive and negative ways.

This is a practice test for carbon made by AI. The student used Gemini to make the practice test. Photo credit to Walker Nunley.

Senior Ian McPherson has strong opinions about AI. McPherson has watched AI become a big part of school life, and has seen it impact education in various ways.

“I think overall, it negatively affects education. AI can be used for actual good purposes, and actual bad purposes. But I think for the most part, with AI coming to education, it has worsened education,” McPherson said. “It makes it much easier for students to not actually do the work or do the learning. It has its benefits– it can help. It offers a lot of ways to make things easier, but with that comes not doing your own work.” 

McPherson believes that banning AI as a whole is a bit drastic, and there are solutions to issues that have been found with AI.

“The goal shouldn’t be to just put a complete blocker or stop AI as a whole. Because AI, as an innovation, is really quite amazing, and, again, can be used in very helpful ways,” McPherson said. “If there are alternatives, that would be best. Instead of having just a complete hard block, like no AI on things, having specific restrictions would help so you can’t use AI to harm.” 

McPherson hopes that AI will be more controlled in the future, since it can be a useful tool.

“I know there’s certain things like math help that you can get from AI. I’m hoping that there will be certain measures that can be taken so that only the helpful things of AI can be used,” McPherson said.

This is the AI usage paper hung in the classrooms. Staff hung these up at the beginning of the year. Photo credit to Walker Nunley.

Freshman Nickolas Seitz is against AI being on chromebooks because he thinks it is harmful to students.

“It limits the amount of creativity that students should use on projects and assignments. AI will further promote not doing your own work, and will take away creativity and personality,” Seitz said.

English teacher Kathy Vogel is on the AI committee which makes decisions about how teachers and students can navigate AI and use it responsibly. Vogel has a love-hate relationship with AI, she understands it’s a helpful tool, but also recognizes it can be harmful.

“AI can be a good thing because it can help you brainstorm and other things. But the sad fact of it is too many of our students are using it to shortcome their own learning, to not go through the struggles of being a writer. Instead, they want a quick fix, a quick answer, and so from the teaching end, that’s very frustrating,” Vogel said.

Vogel does not believe AI itself is a bad thing; she believes that students should know how to use it because it’s our future.

“In general I am not against AI. I recognize that it’s here to stay, and that we need to equip our students with experiences using AI. Students should have some knowledge on using AI and the power behind it, so that they’re not behind their peers,” Vogel said. “I’m not against it. I can see in certain classes where you could take advantage of building things around AI. But in the English department, it’s become difficult because many students don’t want to put the work in developing themselves as writers and thinkers.”

AI being used on assignments can be a big problem. Vogel has experienced a shocking amount of misused AI on assignments last year.

“Last year in my senior English class, over 80% of the kids used AI on their Great Gatsby test. That’s crazy to me. It zaps so much of my time that could be used for building stronger lessons or giving good feedback because then you have to sit down with the kids one-on-one to talk about their use of AI. So it’s really draining for a teacher,” Vogel said.

Ai is a tool for teachers as well. Vogel explains how it can be used to make a time consuming part of teaching easier.

“Teachers can use AI to help give students immediate feedback on that formative practice. That feedback’s immediate because when you have a caseload of between 110 and 140 students, it’s impossible to give timely feedback,” Vogel said. “Teachers could use it as a way for students to have formative feedback. But you can’t solely rely on that.”

Advanced Placement Literature teacher (AP Lit) teacher Megan Porter believes AI has drastically changed the way teachers have to look at their students’ work because of AI usage.

“Teachers now have to look through this different lens that we never had before, about where the students’ work really comes from. And it’s not a ton of cases, but it does make us feel a little bit jaded when it comes to certain things,” Porter said.

Porter believes there is so much we don’t know about AI, that it’s difficult to make big decisions on it.

“We don’t know enough about the repercussions of AI to be able to make an answer on whether schools are better off with or without AI,” Porter said.

Brandon Paradis is a robotics teacher in the technology department. Because of the nature of his class, he has a different perspective than most teachers.

“I really feel that AI was meant to help us with the things we don’t want to do–the mundane things. But I think AI is being used as a substitute for critical thinking. I think that needs to really adjust because AI is supposed to be a tool, not the brain,” Paradis said.

Paradis thinks AI should be in schools. But maybe after it has been further developed and considered for school usage.

“If AI is supposed to be this new gen tech wave that we’re all going to be dealing with, then it’s important that students understand AI, and it should be in schools. But I don’t think that it has been developed in a way that it should be in schools yet,” Paradis said.

In the end, there’s reasons AI should stay on chromebooks, and reasons it should be blocked. Blocking AI isn’t the right choice, but putting restrictions on it is. AI is more of an educational tool than anything, and if people decide to use AI harmfully that’s only hurting themselves. Just because some people use it irresponsibly doesn’t mean they should ruin it for everybody else.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*